Bonjour, readers! A little bit ago a fledgling butch wrote in asking for some help in the tomboy department. I handed it over to M and I’m posting the exchange here in case it helps you or a tomboy you know. Enjoy!
Hey FFAF,
I love your blog, not least of all because you are highly enjoyable eye candy (do you mind? Such a silly question! – FFAF), but also because you clearly have an eye for fashion. In fact, you remind me of my own femme. I have to admit though, that I scour your pictures for glimpses of M, and what she’s wearing – also, clearly put together. I was wondering if you could relay a question from me to her.
I’ve realized I’m not in college anymore and I probably shouldn’t wear sneakers everywhere (even though I love them). I’m in desperate need of a pair of shoes to wear to work, but I’ve decided NOT to wear the Stuart Weitzman black patent pumps my mom got for me. I’m sure, as a femme, that your heart is breaking upon hearing this – don’t worry, I’m finding them a good home – but my butch feet just can’t stand them. Plus, my coworkers say I look silly, looking like a rugby player teetering around on tiny little pumps. Ha!
I guess this is my first foray trying to buy butch-appropriate dress shoes. Do you have any tips? I wear a women’s size 8.5, and my understanding is that it translates to a men’s 6.5, narrow width. Is the width important? How do I find these teeny men’s shoes? And how do I make sure that my shoes aren’t “too butch”? Is there such a thing?
Your help is much appreciated…I’m still a newly minted butch. Or, always butch in attitude, finally realizing how to dress. Thanks! - Newly Minted Butch
Dear Newly Minted Butch,
Thanks for writing! Let’s see if we can’t help you sort this out. Unless you have a super skinny foot, the normal width should be fine. Also, depending on the amount of walking to be done, you want to possibly go up half a size to make room for insoles (recommended) and thickness of sock (I don’t like super thin men’s socks, they feel weird on my foot!!).
Therefore, I would start with a normal size 7 and see how those feel. Skater shoes are usually pretty snug to begin with, so I’d go another half size up for that. So, maybe a 6.5 for fancy shoes that won’t be worn everyday, a size 7 for everyday business casual (to make room for an insole), and a size 7 for any athletic/skater shoes.
Much like with clothing – take jeans, for instance – you find that certain brands or lines or stores carry types that suit you best. Shoes are no different! It’s why I tend to stick with a small number of brands, but more about that at the end. Here are an assortment of suggested possibilities in your estimated size to get you started:
Black Leather Oxfords from Kenneth Cole, $115

The Bicycle-Toed Shane Oxford from Fitwell, $91

If you’re anything like me and don’t like laces…Ecco’s New York Hand Sewn Slip-On, $125

Ankle boots are the best! Prada Men’s Chelsea Brown Leather Boots, $400

Skater shoes! Osiris 247 in 4 Color Combos, $64

A note on brands: I like Kenneth Cole shoes for fancy/business, and DC or Adio for skater shoes. For affordable, current, handsome enough ankle-length boots you’ll blast through in a year or so, try Aldo – during sales you can pick up a pair for as little as $50/pair, but they run out of sizes quickly, so act fast. Though if I were super rich, I’d probably just buy a pair of Prada boots and maybe a pair of DSquared2 boots to be ultra-ghey once per year.
Alta 4 Evening Ankle Boot byDSquared2™, $925

Be sure to report back! And don’t, you know, let this stop you from scouring the blog for photos of me in the future!
- M